In a recent controversy, IIT Madras Director V. Kamakoti has faced criticism after making claims about the medicinal properties of gaumutra (cow urine) during a speech at the Go Samrakshana Sala event on Maatu Pongal. Kamakoti recounted an anecdote about a prominent sanyasi who reportedly cured a fever within 15 minutes by consuming gaumutra instead of seeking medical treatment. He described gaumutra as an “important medicine” with anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, and digestive benefits, even suggesting its potential in addressing conditions like irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).
The remarks sparked widespread criticism, with many questioning the scientific validity of such claims. Critics argued that assertions about the medicinal properties of cow urine should be substantiated by rigorous scientific evidence rather than anecdotal accounts.
Amid the backlash, Zoho CEO Sridhar Vembu came to Kamakoti’s defense, emphasizing the growing recognition of traditional remedies in modern science. In a post on X (formerly Twitter), Vembu highlighted Kamakoti’s credentials as an accomplished researcher and educator. “He gave citations to scientific papers on the beneficial properties of cow urine. Modern science is increasingly recognising the value of our traditional insights. Online mobs are simply channelling their own prejudices, not based on any scientific insight,” Vembu wrote.
Urging Kamakoti to remain steadfast, Vembu added, “Stay strong Prof Kamakoti. Don’t give into the attack mobs.”
In a separate post, Vembu elaborated on the parallels between traditional practices and emerging scientific trends. “The people who are mocking cow urine don’t know how fecal transplants and faecal pills (yes!) from very healthy individuals (preferably from pre-industrial societies, not exposed to modern diets) are seeing growing scientific interest due to their role in restoring beneficial gut bacteria,” he stated. Vembu further asserted that gut bacteria play a critical role in immunity and overall health, drawing connections to the potential benefits of cow urine and cow dung.
“So ‘cow urine and cow dung have beneficial properties’ is not some superstitious quackery. Modern science is converging there. It is the closed-minded fanatic who takes part in online mobs,” Vembu concluded.
Kamakoti’s remarks and Vembu’s subsequent defense have ignited a heated debate on the interplay between traditional medicine and modern science, with advocates highlighting the need for further research and critics demanding evidence-based validation for such claims. The incident underscores the broader conversation about integrating traditional practices with contemporary scientific approaches, particularly in India.
